Halloween wouldn’t be complete without a dose of witchcraft and whimsical mischief, and few films embody this spirit better than Hocus Pocus and its sequel, Hocus Pocus 2 now streaming on Disney+. But which is better Hocus Pocus or Hocus Pocus 2? The original 1993 film has become a beloved part of the Halloween movie canon, often watched year after year by families and fans of all ages. When Hocus Pocus 2 arrived in 2022, it had big shoes to fill, promising a return to the quirky, spooky world of the Sanderson sisters for a new generation of viewers.
But if you only have time for one Hocus Pocus movie this Halloween, how do you choose? The original film holds a nostalgic place in the hearts of many, while the sequel attempts to modernise the story with updated visuals and fresh characters.
Both movies are filled with laughs, fun scares, and a touch of heartwarming magic, but they have distinct differences that set them apart. In this comparison, we’ll explore what makes each film special and help you decide which Hocus Pocus adventure to experience this Halloween.
The Original Magic: Hocus Pocus (1993)
The original Hocus Pocus is the epitome of 90s Halloween nostalgia. It tells the story of three 17th-century witches—Winifred, Sarah, and Mary Sanderson—brought back to life in modern-day Salem by a group of kids on Halloween night. From its quirky humour to the witchy antics of Bette Midler, Sarah Jessica Parker, and Kathy Najimy, the film offers a perfect blend of comedy, spookiness, and charm.
What makes Hocus Pocus so beloved is the energy and chemistry of its three leads. Bette Midler’s Winifred is the ultimate over-the-top villain, with her exaggerated expressions and gleeful wickedness stealing every scene. Sarah Jessica Parker plays the airheaded but endearing Sarah, and Kathy Najimy is delightful as the bumbling Mary. Together, they create a hilarious, chaotic trio whose misadventures in the modern world are the heart of the film.
The plot, while simple, is effective in delivering a fun, fast-paced adventure. The kids—Max, his younger sister Dani, and their friend Allison—must stop the Sanderson sisters from achieving their goal of immortality by stealing the life force of Salem’s children. What follows is a series of magical mishaps, chases, and, of course, the unforgettable “I Put a Spell on You” musical number performed by Winifred.
The film’s charm also lies in its Halloween setting. From the foggy streets of Salem to the spooky, candle-lit interiors, Hocus Pocus perfectly captures the atmosphere of the season. Though the special effects may seem dated by today’s standards, they add a nostalgic quality to the film, reminding viewers of a time when family Halloween movies were simple but packed with heart.
How To Watch Hocus Pocus
The New Spell: Hocus Pocus 2 (2022)
Hocus Pocus 2 brings the Sanderson sisters back for a new adventure in 2022. This time, they’re resurrected by a group of modern-day teens who, like their predecessors, accidentally light the cursed Black Flame Candle. The sequel retains much of the playful spirit of the original while updating it with new characters and a more contemporary storyline.
Visually, Hocus Pocus 2 is a big upgrade. The special effects are more polished, giving the film a sleeker look that appeals to a modern audience. The magical sequences are more elaborate, and the cinematography feels grander, which adds to the overall spectacle. From the first moment the witches appear on screen, the film immediately feels like a modernised, bigger-budget version of the original.
Bette Midler, Sarah Jessica Parker, and Kathy Najimy reprise their roles as the Sanderson sisters, and they haven’t missed a beat. Their performances are just as lively and comedic as in the first film, and they slip back into their roles effortlessly. However, the sequel also delves into their backstory, giving the witches more depth and explaining how they became the powerful figures they are. This added layer of character development makes Hocus Pocus 2 feel like more than just a rehash of the original.
However, the sequel doesn’t rely solely on the Sandersons to carry the story. A new group of teens—Becca, Izzy, and Cassie—are at the centre of the plot, and the film explores themes of friendship and self-discovery alongside the magical chaos. While these new characters bring a fresh dynamic to the film, they don’t quite capture the same charm or chemistry as the original trio of Max, Dani, and Allison. Still, they provide a fun new perspective for younger viewers who may be experiencing the Hocus Pocus world for the first time.
Where Hocus Pocus 2 shines is in its self-awareness. The film leans into its legacy, offering plenty of nods and Easter eggs to fans of the original. It’s clear the filmmakers know how beloved the first movie is, and they work hard to honour its legacy while giving the sequel its own identity. However, this heavy reliance on nostalgia could leave some viewers feeling like the sequel doesn’t quite stand on its own as a fully independent film.
How To Watch Hocus Pocus 2
Which Movie Should You Watch This Halloween?
Choosing between Hocus Pocus and Hocus Pocus 2 comes down to what you’re in the mood for this Halloween.
If you’re looking for a classic, feel-good Halloween experience filled with nostalgia, stick with the original Hocus Pocus. Its timeless charm, hilarious performances, and iconic moments make it the definitive Halloween movie for many. The 90s vibe, combined with the fun yet spooky atmosphere, makes it a must-watch every year for fans of all ages.
On the other hand, if you’re interested in a fresh take on the Sanderson sisters and want to see a more visually updated and modern story, Hocus Pocus 2 is a great option. It’s packed with new twists, deeper character exploration, and a bigger focus on friendship and identity, making it an enjoyable sequel that brings the witches into the present day.
So which Hocus Pocus movie should you watch this Halloween? Why not both? Ultimately, the best choice might be to watch both. Start with the original for a dose of Halloween nostalgia, then dive into the sequel to see how the magic has evolved. Whether you’re a long-time fan or new to the Sanderson sisters, there’s something in each film to make your Halloween a little more wickedly fun.